Skip to main content

Belated Mexico: The Bat Cave and Quintana Roo

 

To break up the long drive to Cancun, we planned to stop at Xpujil, near the eastern edge of the Calakmul Biosphere for a couple of days. Starting on the eastern edge of Calakmul and continuing east towards the coast, the forest becomes wetter and many of the species that occur in eastern Chiapas also occur there, although their status is much less well-known. Given that we had limited knowledge of how to access the various sites and we knew that at least some of them were on ejido lands, we hired Claudio Lopez (+52 983 182 6203 on Whatsapp) as a birding guide to maximize our efficiency and avoid potential problems. Claudio turned out to have exceptionally sharp vision, which made both Paul and myself keenly aware that our age was catching up with us!

Before we reached Xpujil we decided to stop off at the bat cave near the entrance to Calakmul. After arriving there, we discovered we had to wait until a guided tour in the evening before we could go in. After waiting about an hour, we made the short walk to the cave. There are often birds around the entrance to bat roosting caves, hoping to snag a bat for dinner during the mass exodus. I had seen a couple of reports of Bicolored Hawk from here and was hoping we might luck out.

Collared Forest-Falcon eating bat

Short after our arrival, the guide leading the tour pointed out a raptor flying around low down near the cave entrance – a Collared Forest Falcon. Apparently, there are almost always one or two present and this may be the closest thing to a guaranteed location for seeing this notoriously cryptic species in Mexico. Unfortunately, we failed to see any sign of a Bicolored Hawk, although we eventually relocated the forest-falcon in the trees above us, dining on a bat. The overall bat spectacle was underwhelming in my opinion, at least compared to Carlsbad Caverns or Ruby Mine. One issue may be the extensive trees that obscure the bat flight to some extent. However, there really seemed to be far fewer bats, especially earlier in the evening.

Crested Guan

We made contact with Claudio that evening and hatched a plan for the next couple of days. The next morning, we drove east from Xpujil into a forest area where Claudio had discovered a large roost of King Vultures. The drive in had some good highlights with both a female Great Curassow and a Crested Guan showing well. We then got on the trail to the vulture roost. This led through typical Atlantic coast rain forest and with Claudio’s knowledge, we were able to clean up on a few missing avian items. First off was a Red-capped Mannakin lek, where we got good looks at both males and females. Next were three Gray-headed Tanagers, a lifer for Paul and a bird I had only seen a couple of times previously. Finally, we saw a male Gray-collared Becard well. This is a localized, low-density species that I ran into quite often in my first wave of trips to Mexico but one that I have rarely seen recently. We had missed it in Oaxaca a couple of years previously and it was a lifer for Paul. We had another Royal Flycatcher that briefly showed its full crest for Claudio, but not for either of us!

Gray-collared Becard

Gray-headed Tanager

We finally arrived at the vulture roost and it exceeded all expectations. I had seen King Vultures half-a-dozen times before, often quite well, but we had very close-range views of at least 15 birds, including both adults and immatures. I will let Paul’s photos speak for themselves ….



Adult and juvenile King Vultures

In the afternoon, we made the long drive back into Calakmul to look at an Ornate Hawk-Eagle nest. We found the nest but unfortunately no sign of the adults and it appeared they had abandoned the location. This was a bit of a downer as this is a really spectacular-looking species I had seen just twice. Our effort was somewhat rewarded when we found a pair of White-necked Puffbirds – a low-density species that is quite difficult to catch-up with.

White-necked Puffbird

We finished the day at the bat cave, since Claudio said it was the most likely spot for a Bicolored Hawk. We missed it again, but this time the Collared Forest-Falcon was complemented by a Barn Owl and a pair of Black-and-white Owls, one of which we saw catching and then eating a bat.

The next morning, we headed south close to the border with Guatemala to visit Dos Naciones, on the SE edge of the Calakmul Biosphere. This had many of the lowland rainforest species that occur in E Chiapas and we were hoping for some of the tropical flycatchers we had missed. The path towards the forest led through cut-over forest, fields and orchards and a Pheasant Cuckoo was a nice addition to the trip list.

Initially birding was slow in the forest, but after crossing up and over a ridge and down into a small side valley, things began to pick up. We finally got a visual on a Black-throated Shrike-Tanager, after only hearing them in Naha. This was a male, my first one as my only previous sighting had been of a female, and we had nice looks. I then found a Sulphur-rumped Flycatcher, which showed well.

Black-throated Shrike-Tanager

One bird I had missed entirely on my previous trip to Chiapas was Ruddy-tailed Flycatcher. Since it occurred in Dos Naciones, I had been diligently keeping up the playback when a likely candidate flew across the trail. Claudio’s eagle eyes saw where it landed and after a brief panic, I got on to the bird and had good looks. We did well with other tropical flycatchers on the trail, seeing Ochre-bellied Flycatcher, Stub-tailed Spadebill and Eye-ringed Flatbill. Unfortunately our luck with tinamous did not change as we spent about 15 minutes trying fruitlessly to tempt a close-by Slaty-breasted Tinamou into view.

Green Vine Snake

On the return out of the forest, we had a great look at a Green Vine Snake that shot across the path and then slid up into a small sapling. Some mobbing playback in the orchard pulled out both Yellow-green and Red-eyed Vireos and a Blue-winged Warbler, among other migrants. By now raptors were starting to soar and we had several good birds including a King Vulture and a Plumbeous Kite.

Plumbeous Kite

We now headed back to Xpujil where we dropped Claudio off and began the drive up towards Tulum. We eventually settled on a fairly early night with a plan to check early next morning an area a bit inland where I had Yucatan Poorwill on a previous trip.

Leaving well before dawn the next day saw us driving some dirt roads through thorn forest. After some initial disappointment, we finally got a response from a Yucatan Poorwill close by. This species is notoriously difficult to see but I had had good luck on my previous trip by illuminating the area while trying to playback. We were able to see the bird flying around in the flashlight beam, but could not track it to where it perched.

We continued birding as it got light and after a while we had a very brief look at a raptor flying over the track. I was fairly confident that the bird might prove to be a Gray-headed Kite and cranked up the playback. We soon hear birds responding a little away from the track and then a bird flew in and perched right above our heads for very good looks. This was only the second time either of us had seen the species.

Since we were not too far from Coba, we then headed up to check out the lagoon in the hope we could tempt out Ruddy Crakes to show better than the ones in the Usumacinta marshes. Although I had good looks during a prior visit, the crakes preferred to remain hidden. Due to last minute change in Paul’s schedule related to medical appointments, we now drove up to the airport for him to catch his flight later that day. Once I had dropped him off, I then turned around and drove back to Tulum as our original schedule had us staying out at Punta Allen.

The original purpose of going out to Punta Allen was to see Rufous-necked Wood-Rail, for which there was supposedly almost a 100% chance. This would have been a lifer for Paul and a bird I had only seen previously a couple of times, both at San Blas in Nayarit. Caribbean Elaenia was also likely there and I was excited about the possibility of seeing some of the rarer (in Mexico) Caribbean migrants, specifically Gray Kingbird and Black-whiskered Vireo.

Michael Carmody, who had told me about the wood-rails there, had warned me about the very slow, pot-holed road out to Punta Allen and stated that he always questioned himself whether it was worth the effort. Despite the fact that there were no lifers out there for me, I bit the bullet and began the long drive out of Tulum.

The road was every bit as bad as Michael had told me, but I persisted. After an hour I had finally reached around halfway when I was stopped and told that due to a forest fire, the road had been closed indefinitely. The fire crew stated that it would be many hours before the road would open. It was obviously useless to go on, so I turned around and “bumpity-bumped” my way back to Tulum. I obviously had “to eat” the money I had paid for the accommodation in Punta Allen and once I was back in a cell phone reception area, I started looking on-line for a place to stay. There was nothing that cheap in Tulum, so I decided to book another night at the hotel inland from Puerto Morelos we had used at the beginning of the trip. I was already using that for the next night, so it was convenient, even though it meant another hour and a half of driving.

The following morning, I started on a search for Gray Kingbird and Black-whiskered Vireo. A few pairs of the former breed along the Caribbean coast of Mexico and it is also a rare to uncommon but regular migrant. The latter is a rarer migrant, but likely regular, allowing for the lack of coverage. There were no recent ebird reports of the kingbird from its regular nesting spot in the Walmark carpark in Cancun, so I decided to just wander around various coastal neighborhoods looking for one, as they perch conspicuously like other kingbirds. For the vireo, I simply played Red-eyed Vireo scolding calls in any area of mangroves or trees I could find. I also visited the botanic gardens both days as these offer extensive tree cover that back right on to the mangroves.

Palm Warbler

The search proved rather dull as I could turn up neither of the two target species and the other bird species were pretty humdrum, although it was nice to see Palm and Yellow-throated Warblers again. I did at least enjoy exceptional looks at three different Yucatan Vireos, which I had only seen perhaps three times previously. On the last visit to the botanic garden, I had some success pulling in some birds along the path between the hardwood forest and the mangroves. These included a Black Catbird and a Rufous-browed Peppershrike and, finally, a Black-whiskered Vireo. The vireo put an exclamation point on the end of the trip as later that day, I drove to Cancun Airport to fly back to California. Other than the ‘heard-only’ gang, I could reflect on a successful trip.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Catching up with some spring migrants

  In my previous post, I alluded to a number of species that are distinctly commoner in spring migration than at other times of the year in Santa Barbara County. In between doing bird surveys up on the Strauss wind farm, near Lompoc, I have been making regular visits to Refugio Canyon, Goleta Slough, Campus Point and the Santa Ynez River to try to catch up with them. I also did a couple of seawatches at Point Conception Lighthouse, part of a volunteer migration monitoring program I organize each spring. The photo above is courtesy of Jamie Chavez. Initially, I failed to have much luck with the best being a few Blue-winged Teals arriving at Area K in Goleta Slough and the Santa Ynez River Estuary. Both my seawatches at Point Conception were not blessed with favorable weather for large movements, but we did have both a male Black Scoter and a breeding-plumaged Rhinocerous Auklet close-in on the water on April 5, while a White-winged Scoter flew by on April 12. Fortunately, things...

Back to Scorpion

 After my relatively successful visit on September 23, a check of the weather revealed that heavy overcast would continue through the weekend. I was able to get pretty much the last place on the boat to Scorpion on Sunday September 28. After a typically uneventful crossing, other than the mandatory dolphin pods, I arrived on the island around 9:45. I started birding in the kayak storage area on the north side of the creek bed by the beach as I could hear a Yellow Warbler-like chip there. I eventually located the bird and confirmed it as a Yellow Warbler, while also seeing a few sparrows in the area. In an attempt to miss the crowds, I headed up the north side of the creek bed before cutting over into the campground. As I reached the edge of the campground I noticed a Merlin dashing around over the tops of the eucalyptus trees and also heard an oriole chattering that transpired to be a Bullock’s. I made my way through the campground, seeing very little there. The second fig patch ...

Spain, Winter 2026: Before the Rain

  Some months ago, I happened to be reading an article about Cardiff Airport in Wales Online and one of the reader comments mentioned how poor Cardiff was in flights compared to Bristol Airport. This was news to me, having left the UK before the explosion of low-cost airlines. I immediately checked into the situation and found that there were flights to many cities in Europe from Bristol and that these were typically a bit cheaper than flying from Heathrow. In fact, if you were prepared to fly with no change of clothes, as my birding friend Chris Lamsdell amusingly put it, the flights were much cheaper. I decided to take advantage of this during future trips to see my relatives in Bristol and hatched a plan for a late winter trip to Spain to catch up with the three species I had tried for and missed the previous year, as well as add various woodpeckers, Lammergeier and Wallcreeper. I allowed for nine full days because of potential issues finding the woodpeckers and, of course, Du...